PointsCard vs Square Loyalty
In the US, Square does not sell loyalty on its own. It comes with Square Plus at $49 per location per month. PointsCard starts at $4.99 and works beside the register you already use.
The short version
Choose PointsCard. You get a wallet card, punch cards or points, customer records, and booking without moving payments to Square or paying $49 a location for the plan that unlocks loyalty.
| What a shop compares | PointsCard | Square Loyalty |
|---|---|---|
| What you pay to start | Sized to the shop. Solo $4.99 for 250 customers. Grow $14.99 for 2,000 customers and 8 staff. Pro $39.99 for unlimited customers and staff, 3 locations. You don’t pay for capacity you don’t use. | $49/mo per location for Square Plus in the US. $149 for Premium. The $0 plan does not include loyalty. |
| Three locations | Pro is $39.99 and includes 3 locations. | Square Plus is $49 per location, so three locations are $147 a month. |
| Register | Keep the one you have. Staff scan a wallet QR. | Built into Square POS. Rewards follow the Square sale. |
| How a customer joins | Save a pass to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. No PointsCard account for the guest. | Sign up at the Square register, website, or invoice. |
| Rewards | Punch cards and points, plus tiers, referrals, and birthday messages. | Points by visit, amount spent, or item. |
| Prepaid and store credit | On the same wallet pass. | Square gift cards are a separate Square feature. |
| Languages | 21. Staff app and guest wallet pass follow one company setting. | English, Spanish, French, and Japanese. |
| Online booking | Included on every paid plan. | Square has booking on its plans. Loyalty itself starts on Plus. |
| Customers and staff | Solo 250 customers. Grow 2,000 customers and 8 staff. Pro unlimited. | Included with the Square plan you already pay for per location. |
If you already run Square, points can land when the sale closes. There is no second scan. That is convenient, and it is the honest reason a Square shop stays with Square Loyalty.
That convenience is bundled with the rest of Square: the per-location software fee, the processing rate on Plus or Premium, and a loyalty program that only exists inside that checkout. You are not comparing two loyalty apps at the same price. You are comparing a $4.99 wallet card with a $49-per-location business system that happens to include points.
PointsCard is the better loyalty program when the job is repeat visits, a customer list, prepaid packs, and booking, and the register is already decided. Use Square Loyalty when you want rewards applied by the Square sale and you are ready to pay for Square Plus at every location.